NWilliams: Created page with "== Layered Software and OpenSSL == OpenSSL isn't just used by "applications", but also by libraries. A sufficiently complex application can have many libraries loaded that c..."

2016-01-26T22:13:41Z

Created page with "== Layered Software and OpenSSL == OpenSSL isn't just used by "applications", but also by libraries. A sufficiently complex application can have many libraries loaded that c..."

New page

== Layered Software and OpenSSL ==

OpenSSL isn't just used by "applications", but also
by libraries. A sufficiently complex application can have many
libraries loaded that call OpenSSL, and the main program may not know it.

For example, libldap, libcurl, Kerberos implementations, and many other
libraries might use OpenSSL. Then there's things like PAM, SASL, and
GSS that are pluggable using dlopen() (or LoadLibrary(), ...) and whose
plugins might use one of those libraries or even OpenSSL directly.

Now, with the lock callbacks: who's responsible for setting them?

Today, each call to set the lock callbacks changes them.

Surprise: set lock callbacks, use locks, have these callbacks changed
under your feet, explode.

It's just not safe for libraries to set lock callbacks... unless all of
them set the same lock callbaks, which... they wouldn't because the lock
callback prototypes don't match, say, standard pthreads functions', thus
each library would have its own callback functions, and who knows how
they'll be coded. So libraries can't set them. Sure, libraries can
check if they've been set and set them otherwise, but this is racy
and fails in threaded applications (e.g., the JVM).

If any threaded code uses OpenSSL prior to initializing callbacks ->
process explodes.

Libraries can't initialize them. That leaves the application.

=== Automatic Self-Initialization is the Solution ===

The solution to the above problems is simple: the OpenSSL libcrypto and
libssl libraries must self-initialize automatically.

Note that relying on run-time linker-loader functionality for self-
initialization (e.g., .init/.fini sections, DllMain()) is generally
frowned upon. The correct way to automatically self-initialize is to
use pthread_once() or InitOnceExecuteOnce(), or to construct a similar
once initializer.

Explicit initialization functions are OK, as long as they are optional
(these may be useful for applications that will chroot, for example).

Finalization should not be required and may not be possible.

API Design Considerations: Initialization Functions Hurt - Revision history

NWilliams: Created page with "== Layered Software and OpenSSL == OpenSSL isn't just used by "applications", but also by libraries. A sufficiently complex application can have many libraries loaded that c..."